Sort:  

Time to hop in a time machine!😈 If Pistachio isn’t the odd one, then it has to be Chocolate (4), since it wasn’t among the original Neapolitan trio.

 16 days ago 

You were so close last time and in this comment, you found the word I was looking for - Neapolitan. Strawberry wasn't in the original Neapolitan either - it was Pistachio, Vanilla and Cherry to depict the Italian flag.

henryclive has got it - https://steemit.com/hive-128129/@quiz-master/stiu78

Damn it! another close one! 😭

 16 days ago 

SO close! When I asked you what "It" was, I thought you'd say Neapolitan Ice Cream!