Sort:  

Aw, you're being too hard on Melody - she's thinking of marriage and doesn't want to be in a constant state of war if their views conflict. Mixed marriages involving different religions are difficult at best

This is true. But you can't push others to have faith even if they appeared to accept it for your sake, it wouldn't be genuine and later it would dissolve making the already established marriage more difficult.

I guess Melody shall be mature enough to discuss the concept of faith with Jay, or to move on with her life.