Rebooting SteemSTEM - Towards an engaged community on the STEEM blockchain!

in #steemstem7 years ago (edited)

I assume all of you have read our rant 3 days ago. If not, you should. Please follow this link before reading on.

Essentially, it was all about engagement. But what is engagement?

ENGAGING EACH OTHER

Engaging with each other means acting as a community - and having fun! But fundamentally, creating the opportunities to have fun within that community.

I recommend reading the comments made by @kryzsec on the previous post. Let it be known that steemSTEM is not just about the money involved. On top of getting a steemSTEM upvote, here are some suggestions:

  • Give tips to users on how to improve their writing (markdown/html, style, format, etc.)
  • Comment and ask questions on others' posts, or even better, create discussions. Of course, this does not mean doing that on every single one of the 300 posts we consider each week, but simply whichever ones you are actually interested in.
  • When writing posts, one could also consider leaving points open to trigger such discussions and questions.
  • Write response posts (please do not attack others, but engage an adult discussion with arguments). This could also be a pair of collaborative posts (author A writes part 1 and author B writes part 2 for instance).
  • Vote on content and comments, either manually or trail the @steemstem vote.
  • Write about something you are passionate about and share it with us.

This list is not exhaustive, but it is a good start!

MORE ABOUT CURATION

It is time to let you know how steemSTEM curation works, in the spirit of transparency.

Our team scours the platform for original and quality content and then decides about the voting strength (small, medium, large) with which the post should be voted. Medium and large votes always require a second curator to double-check and confirm. We also have a moon-ish option that is used maybe 3-4 times a month.

We try to be as generous as possible with the small votes. It is perhaps only a small amount of SBD, but keep in mind this is easily 50 times more than what many users get on STEEM... And what do you think we prefer? Giving 100 SBD to a single individual, or give 25x4 SBD to 25 unique authors?

But sometimes, some posts are really, really great and we are trying to be there to support them as well!

This being said, the rewards we give come mainly from our partnership with @curie, and this comes with some golden rules:

Golden Rule 1

The 18 people in our team (managers, general curators and community curators) are not eligible for this curie vote. In short, the curators and the management get a pay cut for joining the cause (we share the curation and distilled rewards, which gives 2-20 STEEM per person per week for an often full time schedule).

Golden rule 2

Okay, @steemstem has a comfortable delegation. But this doesn't fully compensate: a single individual cannot get more than 2.75% of all steemSTEM votes cast during the last 2 weeks. And this percentage may actually go down in the future. This applies to staff, management, authors; everyone.

We are of course not exempt from the posting standards of steemSTEM either; we have to work hard on our own content just like everybody else.

In summary, the team gives for free. In addition, this takes so much time that they post less. But it is our choice to be a part of this and we are making these sacrifices for a cause we strongly believe in.

So, every time you get a steemSTEM upvote, think about what that means, and think about what you can do in return to make the community a more fulfilling environment.

Why not throw a few comments or votes to any other steemstem-considered posts in exchange? Help us build the community that we alone simply cannot grow. Discover like-minds and engage with them on discord. It's up to you!

CURATION AND HONOR MEMBERS

To try and improve on these problems of engagement inherent on the STEEM blockchain, we have implemented a test scenario that will be deployed item by item at some point next week.

Curation

  • We made our private voting channel public. No more excuses about not knowing what the posts we reward are, and how strongly we reward them... If you see an interesting topic, just click on the link, read and comment (and potentially throw an upvote)!
  • If you have no time to do that but want to use your VP for @steemstem, you can either join our homemade curation bot (check the pinned messages on our discord channel for the how to), or just follow @steemstem on @steemauto (here).
  • If you'd rather not do this, SP delegation is also a solution! With steemconnect and this simple form, it takes at most 5 seconds.

For now, this is simple enough and we hope this will lead to some improvements we can all be proud of.

Honor members

We created the concept of steemSTEM Honor Members. You can apply for the position here. We (@steemstem) will read through the applications, check the qualifications and then pick the ones we think are suited to do this job.
The choice could be made because of their write-ups, their level of engagement, the way they welcome and guide the newcomers, etc.

Our steemSTEM Honor Members will be easily identifiable on the discord. There are three main tasks, from which each honor member can pick one, two or all three:

  • Mentor newcomers and steemians who want to become successful STEM posters (helping inside the general chat room, taking on people who messaged management for help, actively seeking out steemSTEM/related posts to give out advice in the comments).
  • Monitor the (freshly created) public "complaint room", where people can complain about anything (in particular why their super-awesome post has not been curated), and rant in front of everyone. The management and curators will from now on systematically block any private complaint about upvotes; there are more than enough posts in the useful links channel to get even the most naive individuals started.
  • Be our engagement officers, checking the comment/answer/vote behavior of steemstem-supported people. No matter how good their content is, people refusing to engage will naturally see less support from the community.

As a reward, our Honor Members will have access to some secret channels and cool colors for your names on the discord. Who hasn't dreamt about that?

SUMMARY

As of this post, we are back in business, and we will try to make these changes as well as further developing our long-term goals. We're not going to drop this initiative, but it is up to the community to decide whether or not we move forward.

The list of people below is our crew. Each individual has personally opted in to sign and support the message in this post.

Founders: @lemouth, @justtryme90
Managers: @anarchyhasnogods, @mobbs, @suesa
General curators: @kryzsec, @ruth-girl, @zest
Community curators: @aboutcoolscience, @alexs1320, @carloserp-2000, @gentleshaid, @greenrun, @guga34, @iamphysical, @kingswisdom, @sco

Sort:  

Glad you guys are back.

We as well ^^

First of all. Sincere appreciation to steemSTEM and welcome back to a better and greater science community.

Write about something you are passionate about and share it with us.

This point can never be overemphasized. There is this natural flow that comes when you write on what you're passionate about.

Also, we should all seek for what we can do for the community, not what the community would do for us. In so doing, we would grow together with the community.
Together, we can make steemSTEM greater.
I'll also reiterate to others the need to join the voting trail. I'm part of the trail, and it's an honour

Also, we should all seek for what we can do for the community, not what the community would do for us.

This is a great statement!!! That means everything.

I agree! Also seems pretty much a no brain choice that anyone who writes science post should follow the STEM trail. At least you know your vote isn't wasted and every little bit helps greatly.

Sadly enough, many people are yet to join the trail. But I believe that they would make haste to join.
Again; I know that steemSTEM can only get greater

If everyone could think like you... :)

On this point I agree but overall you don't want that. LOL, there would be nothing but chaos.

More VP available also means more strength to make the community growing :)

That's the energetic and positive spirit we need, people!! :)

True we need to be passion what we are doing for the community as a whole because this will only get bigger.steemstem has so much to offer.is not just about the post but engagement.

Exactly.
Passion + engagement = greater community

I fully agree with you, once again ^^

Also, we should all seek for what we can do for the community, not what the community would do for us.

These words are golden bro. Would have said this too but you already did..

That's the spirit bro

Indeed I like the flow of this post, first indicating that steemSTEM is not just about money and explaining how steemSTEM works and its curation activities. I believe anyone whose has the interest of the community at hand will embrace all this suggestions, most especially engagement as it is the bedrock of every community.

But in all, i appreciate this great team and all you have been doing and that which you will do.
Indeed we are on the path to greater days.

Well done to the steemstem management

Thanks! I am looking forward to the future! Let's see how it will be. Together is the key ^^

First of it's good to see STEEMSTEM 2.0 back!

I posted this in discord, and just in case it get's lost in the conversation. My 2c is that amongst the "Honor Members" should we consider the concept of Subject experts? Therefore we have posts/complaints being handled by the people most familiar with that subject.

One other issue Honor members could be subject to victimization from people with high SP.

Honor members will do absolutely NO curation, ever (this would cancel all chances for a curie vote). But I'll keep your idea in the back of my head. For now, we'll try to start with the basics. You're more than welcome to apply if you haven't already :)

And about the SP: We already have @reggaemuffin on our team, maybe there will be more one day. We protect our team (if they acted correctly)

Thank you @suesa that sounds great, and I have applied.

That's a pretty interesting idea and would really make things much easier for the mentors. However, I don't know how simple will it be to implement, or will it become another complex task for the management team. The last thing we want is to put more pressure on the management. But I do like this idea tbh.

Actually, that brings up a point. By "Team" scouring posts, does this imply that everyone including Honor members will seek out posts for curation? If so I would expect that will be self regulating in that curators are more likely to pick out posts made in their area of expertise/interest.

From where things stand at this time, no, the honor members will not be seeking out posts for curation. That will be entirely up to the curators.

As suesa said, curation must stay decoupled from engagement. This is also healthy to avoid too much work for a given person :)

Thanks for sharing your ideas! We take everything :)

I really appreciate the transparency and I think you guys are doing an amazing job. After reading @kryzsec's comment in the last post, I feel as if I could have a bit more fun with my writing. Sometimes, it just comes off too structured. I think the challenge to simply have fun while writing will not only make a better writer, but it will also make my posts a bit easier on the eyes. I also need to be a bit more engaged on Steemit!

I'm unsure if this has been proposed before, but it'd be nice if proven Steemian's could help in the curation process to some degree. Just to help lighten the load a bit.

Thanks for all the hard work everybody!

Problem is, those who help with curation can no longer receive a curie vote. So we need to limit the curation team a bit. But there are plenty of other ways to help the community, just by trying to connect with and help others!

Thanks for sharing your ideas.

Curation is actually fine. The problem is really engagement. This is where help is needed and this is what we ask: everyone starting to take care of each other.

every day we will work harder promoting this wonderful community, but without you the users who publish their quality content day after day this could not be possible, that is why all of us (founders, managers, curators and users) must put our granite to improve and strengthen STEM

Very well said! I hope this will be read by many!

Great you are already back!

I hope many people will read this and follow the suggestions - on #steemstem posts as well as on other post! On the other head I want to encourage authors to upvote (good) comments as well! Why should a great comment deserve less than a mediocre post?

I know many people already do this, still wanted to add it!

Greets, Martin

Let's see. I now look far ahead.

In particular, after the 300 reactions of the former posts (I still haven't answered them all), I really think several of our members will move together with us. I just do not know how many (hopefully more than a bunch)....

I am all for commenting and upvoting comments! Not only by the authors, but by those passing by as well.

A warm welcome to us.
Anything worth doing at all, worth doing well.
To achieve the best of this community, we really need to work together as a team. I considered this post as a "safe our soul" message that needs a deep thought of consideration. The message was so clear and precise, it clearly intimated us many ways to build our community. I do want to believe that everyone is important in this community. It is high time we take up our responsibilities individually without being told. Perhaps, you think that you don't have a huge amount of SP, so your vote give little or no SBD, then your decided no to vote at all, just remember that many droplet of water can fill a bowl. Don't wait untill you have thousands of SP before you delegate SP to this community, even your 100SP can go a long way to build this community. Imagine 100SP delegations from 500 community members, that sum up to 50,000 SP which is even close to the current SP steemstem owns presently. We shouldn't expect non-member of this community to build our community for us.
This is my little submission.
Thanks

Thanks for your message. I totally agree with it!

That was faster than expected!

I'm interested in becoming an honor member- do they remain eligible for steemstem upvotes, or are they excluded like curators are?

I spent some time thinking about my engagement in Steemstem over this little break, and realized that most of my engagement lately has been with the same few people that I follow regularly already through steemstem. I definitely need to just start perusing the tag more for new stuff to read and comment on.

You all have been instrumental in my success on Steemit- I've really found my niche in science blogging, and I never would have been able to keep it up if it wasn't for your support and engagement!

Honor members will do 0 curation, so there will be normal votes :)

Cool, I'll be applying, then!

Glad to see steemstem members I follow for some time applying :)

The break was essential. The comeback needs to be strong, from the community.

Without a doubt steemSTEM has the most highly educated users here on steemit, but the engagement was almost non-existent and we, me included, are equally guilty of this.

Imagine the amount of knowledge and ideas that could have been passed around if we would have been a bit more interactive!! Who knows, the next Stephen Hawking might just be hiding among us, in the steemSTEM community!!

Here's to a new start!! Cheers!!

This group has so much untapped potential. I mean we have everything from high school students with a passion to people holding PhD's. I am not saying for sure that we have someone like Hawking or Einstein here but I do think that if the community worked together... Well we could achieve some amazing things.

I do think that if the community worked together... Well we could achieve some amazing things.

Absolutely!!

Very few were actually paying attention to engagement. Which is why we somehow rang an alarm bell. Let;s hope many have heard it. We will see very soon ^^

I'm very excited to see how this unfolds ^^

me to, TBH ^^