The Organic Fraud

in #steemstem6 years ago (edited)

A significant number of people across the world are using the words organic and natural for denoting 'safe' nowadays. Plenty of conservative states are also endorsing organic products over human-made things. So, what is this deal about organic stuffs? OR, Is there any real deal exists?

of1.jpg

Whatever people celebrate as organic or natural are also chemicals! Whether it is crops grown without chemical fertilizers, fertilizers made from garbage, or traditional medicines, all natural products are nothing but chemicals; no exceptions are entertained!

Let us look into ourselves. The basic unit of life, a cell, is made up of chemical substances such as deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), ribonucleic acid (RNA), proteins, lipids, carbohydrates etc. Moreover, nearly 70% of the human body is a chemical named "dihydrogen monoxide" (DHMO), or "hydroxylic acid"! Oh, that is nothing but the uncommon names of water.

At least one time in your life somebody must have told you to eat only homemade food because restaurant food might contain 'chemicals'. Someone else might have suggested you not to take 'allopathic' medicine as the chemicals in it may damage your organs. You may also have come across people saying "chemicals are the reasons for cancer". Such fear of chemicals is known as chemophobia. Since the advent of modern medicine (wrongly termed as allopathy), pseudoscientific medical practitioners are taking advantage of chemophobia and are stamping many useful chemicals as toxic. They also proclaim that all natural things are safe and human-made substances are potentially poisonous.

Is everything obtained from nature safe?

There exist substances in nature that are threatening to animals (including our species). Those are called natural toxins. Such 'natural chemicals' can cause damages ranging from stomach upset to death to humans . Let me list some of them.

  • In one kilogram of cassava, a staple food of tropical and developing countries, contains one gram of hydrogen cyanide, an extremely toxic substance for our health.
  • Fruits such as apricot, apple, cherry etc., contain either hydrogen cyanide or chemicals like mandelonitrile or amygdalin which can turn to hydrogen cyanide by chemical reactions.
  • Sprouted potato and its outer skin are sources of glycoalkaloids that can cause health problems and lectins in beans can give a bad time to your gastrointestinal tract.

Avoid sprouted potato and wash beans thoroughly to avoid natural toxins. Besides these, oxalic acid, furocoumarins, and cucurbitacins etc., are some other undesirable chemicals to our body.

The hoax about cancer-curing potential of vitamin B17

images.jpg

There was a 'claimed to be' scientific fact about vitamin B17 spreading on the internet that the cancer disease is the deficiency of this vitamin. And people believed that the food supplements containing this so-called vitamin could cure cancer. In fact, vitamin B17 is another name of amygdalin which I mentioned as a cyanide forming chemical above. The essential vitamins that we include in the 'B-complex' do not contain B17. The United States' Food and Drug Administrations (FDA) enlisted amygdalin as a toxic chemical in the early 1980s itself. Still, no one has come up with a proof of its cancer-curing potential. But it is 100% sure that it can cause cyanide poisoning to a healthy human.

Cancer and chemicals

Cancer is a set of disease conditions arisen by uncontrolled multiplication of cells in an organ. In a process called metastasis, cells of an affected organ can propagate through the bloodstream and reach other parts of the body to form cancer in a different organ. Cancer is the after effect of alteration in DNA molecules (a process known as mutation) that determines almost everything in each of our cells. Succeeding generations inherit these mutations as parents pass there DNA to offspring. People with such ‘genetic predispositions’ are at high risk to fall prey for cancers. Some chemicals known as carcinogens, radiation, and a few viruses can cause DNA mutations that can result in cancers. Unhealthy food habits, tobacco, and obesity also can increase risk.

cancer-389921_960_720.jpg

In a recent report, scientists have identified that the majority of cancers are caused by random mutations in DNA, which happens all times in our body. Although there is an efficient mechanism to repair such random mistakes, there is a chance of error every 100 million nucleotides (building units of DNA). These may lead to cancer if it occurs at specific parts of DNA that control growth and division of cells.

Currently, although we have better treatments for cancers and increasing survival rates, pseudomedicine is becoming a roadblock to efficient use of the best. The fraud doctors who are also advocates of organic and natural products are spreading hoaxes like "cancers are the after effect of bad lifestyle and consumption of food containing chemicals only". They also have natural and easy remedies such as amygdalin containing diet that I mentioned earlier. Even now, approaching such frauds and delaying the modern therapy and this is causing a large number of cancer deaths in developing countries. Cancer treatment involves chemotherapy, radiation therapy, surgery and, targetted therapy. No one has identified a shortcut to cure cancers.

The policymakers in the healthcare sector should pay at most attention to fraudulent treatments for cancers. Spreading hoaxes and practicing dangerous health treatments should be legally encountered by states. Moreover, cancer therapies should get high priority in the healthcare policy making.

Organic farming

There are strict guidelines by food and drug regulatory agencies across the globe to avoid carcinogens in food additives and fertilisers. All chemical compounds that can be added to eatables as colouring agents, preservatives etc., are strictly under lens from time to time. But chemophobia is a never-ending problem and eyebrows are continuously up against such chemicals; this fertilizes the soil for organic farming. The so-called organic vegetables are remarkably popular, and their ‘no added chemical fertilizers’ tag increases the market value as well. Continues organic farming will deplete essential elements in soil that helps in the healthy growth of plants and the yield will decline eventually. So the usage of chemical fertilizers is a must for food security in a world with poverty and malnutrition taking lives of millions.

In fact, agriculture itself is against nature. That makes organic farming an oxymoron if you consider organic as natural. A single plant species occupying a vast piece of land is an extremely rare natural scene. From the time immemorial humans cultivate plants against the will of nature, to feed their exploding population - another anti-nature activity. So it is a bad idea to consider agriculture as organic.

So, what is not a fraud?

Well, everything that we do for the survival as a species must be written at the bottom of this list. Nature is already suffering from almost everything that we did here. We are already in a ‘struggle to live mode’ on earth. Good quality life on earth demands better health for everyone. Along with people who do not care for others, scientifically illiterate ones are also causing damage to society. Thus hoaxes are created, and fraudulent practitioners emerge.

Put an effort to avoid frauds. Educate yourself and the people around you to stay away from fake news. Scientific temper is the key to a better life; embrace it.

Reference and suggested readings

  • Cell : [Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cell_(biology)
  • Kunkel, Thomas A. "DNA replication fidelity." Journal of Biological Chemistry 279.17 (2004): 16895-16898.
  • FDA warning about amygdalin
  • Natural toxins in food : WHO's report
  • Mutation
  • Tomasetti, Cristian, Lu Li, and Bert Vogelstein. "Stem cell divisions, somatic mutations, cancer etiology, and cancer prevention." Science 355.6331 (2017): 1330-1334.
  • Image 1 and 3 are taken from Pixabay - Free images library
Sort:  

Initially, your position seems to be that since everything is chemicals, then chemicals are safe to eat.

But then you go on to say that in nature, some things are poisonous, even though they're also chemical like all others things.

So? We've evolved alongside certain things that we ate, like free-range organic chicken eggs, for instance. We evolved to eat them. Who knows what happens when you raise those chickens in boxes that don't allow them to move, feed them feed they didn't evolve to eat, and douse them with antibiotics? What's the result or such treatment: a chemical poison or a chemical food?

That's why we do testing. But still, long-term effects are hard to measure. Things we used to think were not poisonous were later discovered to be so.

So I think the less we meddle with food (i.e. the more organic it is), the less chances there are that things might go wrong. It's like a machine: the more parts it has, and the more you fiddle with it, chances increase that something will go wrong.

What do you think?

Actually toxicity depends on the dose. The initial explanation about 'everything is a chemical' was to address chemophobia. My point is if we have control over the chemicals that we consume, it is perfectly alright.

We always meddled with the food; that's how we got high yielding crops, well producing animals etc. We nurtured whatsoever we found good. Almost all the fruits were less sweet and tasty. We overgrew the better ones that gave pleasure to our taste buds. As a result, now those species dominate over the lesser tasty ones.

We have to continue meddling with the food. Otherwise availing nutritious food for the ever exploding population would be extremely difficult.

Another solution of course would be to have no more than 1 child for every 1 person (i.e. 2 per couple), but that I guess is too radical.

Of course that would mean that the economy would collapse because older people are living longer, which would necessitate the discovery of scientific immortality to enable everyone to work, but that's a whole other issue.

As you said, education is what matters. It is important to double check anything weird, especially if it is supposed to be the miracle remedy for this or that important disease.

Personally, I don't eat organic. I eat local. I know how the food is produced, I trust how the food is produced and I chat with the producer on local markets. This is how I am making myself my own ideas about the level of trust I can put in the food I eat. In addition, eating local is good for the environment (better than eating organic food growing on the other side of the world at least).

Glad that you read the post and thanks for sharing your views. Eating local is a very good idea to reduce carbon footprint.

One reason why I prefer organic food, especially meat, eggs and milk: the animals have a better life. Might be not that much better, some square centimeters more per chicken etc., but for me it's worth the higher price.

Thanks for reading. There is always a trade of between available square inch per chicken and death of a malnourished child in a poor country.

I don't think the living conditions of German chickens have any influence on the nutritional status in other countries ;)

Posted using Partiko Android

problem has to be addressed by considering the the entire world as one. While advocating for animal rights, we are not considering the poor fellow-humans who cannot afford protein rich food. Let us say we stop producing chicken in the modern way. The organic way is definitely costly and less yielding. Market price is obviously higher also. If the price is very high, how could we avail that in a poor country where people are starving? Chicken is just an example, consider any organic product now. Traditional ways cannot answer the ever increasing starving population problem.

Your balance is below $0.3. Your account is running low and should be replenished. You have roughly 10 more @dustsweeper votes. Check out the Dustsweeper FAQ here: https://steemit.com/dustsweeper/@dustsweeper/dustsweeper-faq

Great post, you make a lot of valid points about the fear mongering that surrounds the hype of organic products. However, you bring up the argument that organic farming will deplete the soils of their essential nutrients, which is only partly valid. Organic farmers can, and many tend to, rotate crops and fields so that nutrients are replenished. Though, it is difficult to do this on an industrial sized scale. This is why it’s important to eat local, as @lemouth mentioned. Industrial sized operations tend towards monoculturing which in and of itself is disasterous. Many local farmers tend towards the same, but it is becoming more prevalent to work with co-supportive and symbiotic organisms. Farms are able to produce more with less land and less input from the farmer as far as the addition of nutrients and pesticides.

Thanks for a valid input. Hope the readers will go through the comments too.

I agree 100%. Organic is now an industry too, and the bad points are now compensating the good ones in many cases.





This post has been voted on by the SteemSTEM curation team and voting trail in collaboration with @curie.

If you appreciate the work we are doing then consider voting both projects for witness by selecting stem.witness and curie!

For additional information please join us on the SteemSTEM discord and to get to know the rest of the community!

Congratulations @midhunkm! You have completed the following achievement on the Steem blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :

You received more than 250 upvotes. Your next target is to reach 500 upvotes.

You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word STOP

Do not miss the last post from @steemitboard:

3 years on Steem - The distribution of commemorative badges has begun!

You can upvote this notification to help all Steem users. Learn how here!

Sorry to !sneeze here

You have been infected by the King of Disease!

Will you quarantine yourself?

Or will you spread the plague?

King Of Disease

Hello @midhunkm! This is a friendly reminder that you can download Partiko today and start earning Steem easier than ever before!

Partiko is a fast and beautiful mobile app for Steem. You can login using your Steem account, browse, post, comment and upvote easily on your phone!

You can even earn up to 3,000 Partiko Points per day, and easily convert them into Steem token!

Download Partiko now using the link below to receive 1000 Points as bonus right away!

https://partiko.app/referral/partiko