Autism and Gender Dysphoria

in #steemstem7 years ago

(This post was written by a "friend" for a local paper but it go rejected because pro-trans stories by actual trans people don't sell papers. It's a response to the BBC documentary "Transgender Kids: Who Knows Best?" by Dr Zucker which argued that trans people might just be autistic and I hope this article shows that trans people and the medical establishment do.)

This post is based purely on my own personal views and anecdotes, and I make no claim of any scientific basis.

Yes, I am an autistic trans woman, and personally, I am not offended by the claim that there may be a causal like between autism and gender dysphoria. The problem lies in the interpretation of this statement, and the conclusions that we draw from it. One possible conclusion, (and this is one that Dr Zucker has expressed) is that trans people may actually not be trans, but instead have autism. The problematic word here is 'instead'. This word implies that the two conditions are mutually exclusive, which we know as an absolute FACT is not the case: there are many trans people on the autistic spectrum. It's a false dichotomy, namely that a person is either transgender OR autistic, and that both cannot co-exist.

My personal view is that there may indeed be a link between autism and gender dysphoria. Many of the trans people I know are on the autistic spectrum (I know, this is a personal anecdote), and I have long suspected this link. Instead, I believe that there may be a multiple things that can cause gender dysphoria, autism being just one of them. I am certainly by NO means implying that all trans people have autism or that all autistic people are transgender. That would just be silly.

So, what does this mean for the trans community? In my opinion: nothing. Absolutely nothing. Regardless of the cause of gender dysphoria, it is not something that can be 'cured'. Autistic trans people shouldn't not transition simply because autism may be the potential cause. The root cause of our gender dysphoria does not make our identity any less valid. Dysphoria is dysphoria, regardless of cause.

What does it mean for me? Again: nothing. I do not care of the cause. I know that I am transgender. Is it my autism that has caused it? I honestly do not know the answer to that question, but the truth is that it doesn't matter. I know my identity, and I am finally comfortable with who I am.

Of course, there is another possibility that I have considered, and that quite a few people have mentioned previously: It could be that there is an equal distribution of transgender people in both autistic and neurotypical communities; but it is more likely that the autistic trans people will 'come out', whereas the neurotypical trans people will hide it more and attempt to conform with society's expectations. This is another theory that makes sense to me too.

Sort:  

from what I've read people with autism have a predisposition to lot's of other mental conditions

And vice versa. A lot of trans people develop mental health issues when dealing with dysphoria.

In many ways the whole debate is like a simple case of correlation doesn't equal causation.
And like the author says if some trans people happen to be autistic who cares? Even if it did cause it it doesn't invalidate their gender.

I wasn't really talking about mental health issues, I was talking more stuff like Alexithymia

I hadn't even heard of that before...
interesting point! (unfortunately I am not knowledgeable enough to comment- hopefully someone else is though)

I just looked it up too, I was looking for the specific one I was thinking of but I could find it. ripo

actually that was, it just does multiple things. I should finish reading something for once in my life smh

I think this was a good post criticizing the Dr. and his claims. Hope that your friend considers to actually make an account and decides to write more articles. We could use more people like your friend in Steemit.

I will make to sure to send this to her and suggest it. :)

That sounds good. Hope your friend accepts the request. Would be great to add numbers to this community as a whole and to the LGBT particular of this Steemit community.

The @OriginalWorks bot has determined this post by @green-grace to be original material and upvoted it!

ezgif.com-resize.gif

To call @OriginalWorks, simply reply to any post with @originalworks or !originalworks in your message!

As someone transgender and autistic, thank you for this.

Congratulations @green-grace, you have decided to take the next big step with your first post! The Steem Network Team wishes you a great time among this awesome community.


Thumbs up for Steem Network´s strategy

The proven road to boost your personal success in this amazing Steem Network

Do you already know that awesome content will get great profits by following these simple steps, that have been worked out by experts?

Congratulations @green-grace! You received a personal award!

1 Year on Steemit

Click here to view your Board

Support SteemitBoard's project! Vote for its witness and get one more award!

Congratulations @green-grace! You received a personal award!

Happy Birthday! - You are on the Steem blockchain for 2 years!

You can view your badges on your Steem Board and compare to others on the Steem Ranking

Vote for @Steemitboard as a witness to get one more award and increased upvotes!