What Critics Are Saying About BBC’s "Domino Day" (Plus My Two Cents)

Alright, let’s chat about Domino Day, the new BBC Three fantasy horror series that dropped on January 31, 2024. It’s a six-parter about a young witch named Domino, played by Siena Kelly, who’s figuring out her powers in modern Manchester. I’ve been keeping an eye on this one because I’m a sucker for anything witchy, and the buzz has been pretty interesting. Here’s what the critics are saying, plus some of my own thoughts after binging a few episodes.

It’s Got Big Buffy Vibes, But It’s Still Finding Its Groove

Critics are digging the vibe Domino Day is going for. Digital Spy says it’s got the potential to “recapture the glory days of fantasy horror on terrestrial TV,” comparing it to classics like Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Charmed, and Being Human. They think fans of those shows will vibe with it, but they also say it’s “still finding its feet,” much like Domino herself. I totally get that—there’s something nostalgic about the setup, but it doesn’t quite have that polished feel of Buffy yet. I mean, I grew up on Buffy, so maybe I’m a bit biased, but I’m rooting for this show to get there.
The Standard calls it a “witchy drama [that] oozes attitude,” which I totally agree with. The aesthetic is on point—Domino’s outfits are fire, and the whole Manchester backdrop gives it a gritty, urban edge. But they also point out that the magic doesn’t feel… well, magical. They mention the effects, like Domino “sucking gold light out through [a character’s] mouth while the lights go crazy,” and say it’s a bit underwhelming, probably because of BBC’s budget constraints. Honestly, I felt that too. The magic scenes are cool in concept, but they don’t give me the chills I was hoping for. Still, I’m here for the drama, so I can let that slide for now.

• Domino Day is now on Netflix

Siena Kelly Is Killing It

One thing everyone agrees on: Siena Kelly is a star. The Standard says she’s “great as the rather traumatised Domino,” and I couldn’t agree more. She’s got this intensity that makes you feel for Domino, who’s dealing with some heavy stuff while trying to control her powers. Digital Spy points out that she gives off “antagonist vibes” at first, which I thought was such a cool choice—it keeps you guessing about her. I love how Kelly handles the role; she’s got this raw energy, and all the screaming (and wind effects, lol) really sells the chaos of being a witch on the run. I’m already a fan of her from Adult Material, so seeing her shine here is awesome.

It’s Dark and Gritty, Which I Love

Since it’s on BBC Three, Domino Day gets to be a bit darker and more adult than if it were on BBC One. Digital Spy mentions this, saying it lets the show lean into the grittier side of fantasy horror. I’m all about that—it feels more real when things get messy, you know? But they also say the supporting cast isn’t fully fleshed out yet, with “some characters in the coven far more developed than others.” I noticed that too. Like, I want to care about the coven, but some of them feel like they’re just there to fill space. Hopefully, they get more depth if there’s a second season.

Could It Bring Back British Fantasy Horror?

Critics are hopeful that Domino Day might kickstart a revival of British fantasy horror on TV. Digital Spy says its success could “help lead a resurgence,” and I’m crossing my fingers for that. The Standard calls it a “Harry Potter and Buffy the Vampire Slayer smoothie,” which is such a fun way to put it. It’s not perfect, but it’s got heart, and I can see it growing into something big if it gets the chance.

My Take (what you have been waiting for all the time)

Personally, I’m really enjoying Domino Day. It’s not flawless—the magic effects could use some work, and I want to connect more with the side characters—but there’s something about it that keeps me hooked. Maybe it’s the way it mixes modern-day struggles with supernatural chaos, or maybe it’s just Siena Kelly being a total badass. Either way, I’m here for it, and I hope it gets a second season to really find its stride. If you’re into witchy dramas with a bit of edge, it’s worth checking out on iPlayer. What do you guys think—anyone else watching?