I'm not even sure what you are debating at this point... I never said the bottom was for sure in, I said the 3 month downtrend has been broken, which it has. If the price ends up pulling back and making a lower low that won't change the fact that it broke that 3 month downtrend. It will be a new downtrend at that point. My comment was that when you get a downtrend break like the one we are seeing now, it is "usually" good for a multi week bounce, if not more. That is all I have said, nothing more nothing less.